Moderator: Zaxxon
The latter plus one other factor.Unagi wrote:Was it his probing for Baltar data, or the way he suddenly became one of the most active players?
I agree, something is semi-funky right now with the unclaimed specials.Bakhtosh wrote:We have 6 people claiming Citizen. Rev's last post (or the next to last) contained his claim.
That's simply not possible. Either 10 is active (and lost his powers, so can't even fake his own role), or we have a a roled character keeping quiet...and it's hurting the good guys.
stessier wrote:Some concluding thoughts:I guess that is about it. I've seen things that can't be forgotten (no, I'm not Baltar), and it's time for me to go.
- I'm nothing worth keeping around and please don't scan me tonight.
- etc...
Good Luck!
Citizen Stessier
Bakhtosh wrote:Lassr, I asked earlier: did ChaosRaven publicly announce that he would be hiding last night?
Do you think this was enough for the Cylons to figure out he may be hiding?Chaosraven wrote:As both Proven Victims called for me to be protected by Starbuck last night, thereby allowing me to protect myself tonight, I was an invalid target and both of them open.
Grundbegriff wrote:
- Apollo : ?
- Baltar : ?
- Tory : ?
- Citizen1 : ?
- Citizen2 : ?
- Citizen3 : ?
- Citizen4 : ?
- 7 : ?
- mipe = <human>
- Scoop20906 = <human>
- Mr. Bubbles = ?
- Semaj = ?
- stessier = ?
- redrun = ?
- RevHempus = ?
- Unagi = ?
Fixed Stess for you. He autopsied as human.Grundbegriff wrote:Grundbegriff wrote:
- Apollo : ?
- Baltar : ?
- Tory : ?
- Citizen1 : ?
- Citizen2 : ?
- Citizen3 : ?
- Citizen4 : ?
- 7 : ?
- mipe = <human>
- Scoop20906 = <human>
- Mr. Bubbles = ?
- Semaj = ?
- stessier = <human>
- redrun = ?
- RevHempus = ?
- Unagi = ?
I only marked living humans as <human>.Bakhtosh wrote:Fixed Stess for you. He autopsied as human.
I see what you mean-- nevermind. Scoop and stessier are dead humans.Grundbegriff wrote:I only marked living humans as <human>.Bakhtosh wrote:Fixed Stess for you. He autopsied as human.
Somewhy, I take that as an offence :/ DO YOU PERHAPS KNOW A REASON?Grundbegriff wrote:Bear in mind that during the midgame mipefest, mipe did briefly claim to be Baltar before withdrawing the claim and playing it off as a joke.
I think he did:Bakhtosh wrote:Stess was a good guy. Why would he not reveal as Tory/Baltar?
If he had been a mere citizen, would he have bothered to say "don't scan me. No one will fake me."? Why say something explanatory instead of just saying "I'm a Citizen"?And now that I'm dead...if Apollo really is alive...don't scan me. No one will fake me. Good luck fellow Citizens!!!
Don't be coy, mipe.mipe wrote:Somewhy, I take that as an offence :/ DO YOU PERHAPS KNOW A REASON?Grundbegriff wrote:Bear in mind that during the midgame mipefest, mipe did briefly claim to be Baltar before withdrawing the claim and playing it off as a joke.
-- If we knew that Baltar was one of the four unknowns, we'd have someone who couldn't be #7 or #10 - increases our cylon kill chances.Grundbegriff wrote:The latter plus one other factor.Unagi wrote:Was it his probing for Baltar data, or the way he suddenly became one of the most active players?If we kill redrun and he's #7 (as I expect) and the game doesn't end, I'd look to purge first as the convert.
- First, nothing else explains redrun's rise from lowest profile to highest. That's the behavior of either a sleeper or a convert.
- Second, if RevHempus were a sleeper or convert, he'd have gone from low profile to high, and he hasn't.
Scoop20906 wrote:As long as every realizes the drawback to the specialists coming out, namely:
A) If an unknown claims specialist, the can still be activated and turn into #10.
Even if Purge says "I'm a specialist" and Grund says, "Yep, I am a specialist and I confirm Purge", then Purge is still an unknown and must be scanned or killed.
And, I just noticed that Baltar will take over autopsy if both specialists are killed (but we lose one day in between). This could create an interesting scenario (which Lassr handled wisely) where if Grund and Purge announce they are specialists and Grund is killed and on the same night Purge is activated then we will not get a autopsy that night and then Baltar will take over autopies the next night.
I don't recall. I'm also not finding where Scoop stated his role unambiguously. Links?Bakhtosh wrote:Claiming Tory would have likely saved his life since he could give us a human we didn't need to scan (unless that human had already been scanned - mipe). Athena could have confirmed that we could trust him and his scan.
He did specifically claim is was not Baltar, didn't he?
Scoop20906 wrote:I agree that the two specialist must come out.
Its possible we have only one or only two cylons left.
We are pretty lucky that we have such a small pool of unknowns
Scoop20906 ---
Unagi ---
RevHempus ---
redrun ---
purge ---
I realize many of you think I would be a good person to kill today. However, I know I am a citizen so I disagree.
Out of the unknowns I am the most leery of Unagi but I think today would be a smart time to take out one of the less active players in case it comes down to them late in the game.
I suggest today's lynch target be RevHempus.
RevHempus
For someone who hadn't posted in the game for 2 days prior to this post, he sure had a great grasp of the mechanics of #7's abilities...something that confused several people for a while.RevHempus71 wrote:Ok, 2 dead last night. So # 7 is deffinately alive. Meaning that the dead Cylons are a combination of Six, 10, Cavil. Without Apollo coming forward we have no way to know for sure wich 2 are the dead cylons.
I believe Scoop
is our badguy. His little code, now more than ever looks like 7 trying to signal the others.
Note the characteristics.redrun wrote: -- If we knew that Baltar was one of the four unknowns, we'd have someone who couldn't be #7 or #10 - increases our cylon kill chances.
Posting pattern - I'm new here, I'm learning this version of the game - so for the start of the game I was more comfortable with posting less while I learned the tone and manner of discussion here. As folks have died and I've learned more, I've posted more.
Mipe - I think you need to state again who you are. I see a major danger that Unagi & I are both seeing a false claim for Citizen based on seeing you as a citizen . If you are not a citizen, you need to say such. We can't ask Scoop and Stessier. If I die, then Unagi will be in the hot seat. If Unagi dies and comes up human, then I'm in the hot seat - and it would pretty bad if we both came up human.
Gotta run, will check back in about 3 hours.
stessier wrote:Some concluding thoughts:I guess that is about it. I've seen things that can't be forgotten (no, I'm not Baltar), and it's time for me to go.
- I'm nothing worth keeping around and please don't scan me tonight.
- etc...
Good Luck!
Citizen Stessier
Not really. For example, 7 only takes the reins if both Cavil and Six are dead -- and 10 if 10 has already been converted -- and yet Rev comes across as muddled about who must be dead in light of the explosion.Bakhtosh wrote:For someone who hadn't posted in the game for 2 days prior to this post, he sure had a great grasp of the mechanics of #7's abilities...something that confused several people for a while.RevHempus71 wrote:Ok, 2 dead last night. So # 7 is deffinately alive. Meaning that the dead Cylons are a combination of Six, 10, Cavil. Without Apollo coming forward we have no way to know for sure wich 2 are the dead cylons.
I believe Scoop
is our badguy. His little code, now more than ever looks like 7 trying to signal the others.
Why didn't he say "No, I'm neither Baltar nor Tori"?Bakhtosh wrote:stessier wrote:Some concluding thoughts:I guess that is about it. I've seen things that can't be forgotten (no, I'm not Baltar), and it's time for me to go.
- I'm nothing worth keeping around and please don't scan me tonight.
- etc...
Good Luck!
Citizen Stessier
"
I hope you don't hate me,
I hope you find in it in your heart,
that I just can't make it in this world alone,
For I must go,
My heart is crashin' and burnin',
My hair is gone,
My heart is beatin' hard,
And Doctor comes in,
Sayin' hold on my dear,
But I say,
Its time for me to go,
Cause without your love,
baby,
I'll die alone,
Hope you know,
inside my heart,
I'm crushin' on you,
But I just can't find the words to say,
What I really wanna say,
I'll die with dignity,
knowing you'll be okay,
And Doctor will say,
He died today,"
In the last few episodes of season 3, her mental condition starts deteriorating, and she starts hearing music.
Maybe to leave options open for his team? There's no good reason for a Cylon to emulate Tory (though one might), but there could be good reasons for a Citizen to do so.Bakhtosh wrote:But why NOT reveal his role? He had plenty of time to make his reveal. Why would Tory not reveal?
Scoop20906 wrote:Scoop walks back into the conference room.
He notices Grund is now standing on the conference table proclaiming to those seated there. Unagi sits directly under Grund staring at him with bright eyes and nodding vigorously like a terrier puppy. Chaosraven and Bahktosh are at the end of he table in a very quiet conversation. Revhempus is at the other end of the conference staring off into space and bobbing his head. Mipe is still curled up under the conference table snoring loudly.
"Ahh, looks who has come to join us." Grund announces grandly, "You're just in time to hear my grand statement of how we rid ourselves of the Cylon menace that inhabit this freighter with us."
Scoop ignores Grund and says, "Ok, I know I hear something. Its like a ..."
"Like a tune?" Unagi finishes Scoop's statement.
"Yeah. But, more like a song, some like ... " Scoop hums something.
"Yeah, I have been hearing it too." Unagi turns to Rev and shouts, "REV!!!"
Rev pops out of his trance and looks in Unagi's direction, "Huh, What?". Small ear buds drops of our Rev's ear and music can be heard coming from them.
"Turn down your I-Pod!" yells Unagi.
Grund signs dramatically, "Can we please get back to my proclaimation?"
Unagi turns back to Grund and nodds eagerly as Scoop heads back to his bunk shaking his head.
Scoop20906 wrote:Scoop walks into the conference room from his cabin rubbing the sleep out of his eyes looking cranky...
Scoop notices most of the group sits around the conference table quietly discussing the possibilities of the day. Mipe is curled up in the fetal position under the conference table mumbling in his sleep.
Scoop asks, "Does anyone hear that sound?"
Bahktosh looks up and says "What sound?"
"I don't know. But, I keep kind of hearing something like a ... but then it's gone.", responds scoop.
Unagi looks at Scoop skeptically, "Is this another one of your tricks? Like that code you scratched out on the wall of your bunk?"
"No one hears anything?", asks scoop again tapping his ear.
"Go sell crazy somewhere else, scoop." purge remarks, "were all full here."
Scoop shakes his head and walks back to his bunk.
