Warhammer 40K - Game Called- New roles to be sent out.

[Remus West]

I vote reroll

[Scoop20906]

I think I need to call the game. I gave wrong information to the EC about one of thier scans that could have effected the game. They scanned a special and told them that it was a normal. I corrected the error, but I think I need to be fair to both sides. I would like opinion if we should carry on?

Well, this is a monday morning wake me up.

Ok, let me see if I get this straight. The baddies scanned someone and you told them that they were a normal but you corrected the error.

Did you correct the error before they chose who to kill? I am guessing not.

So, now we know that the baddies either,

A) Scanned Remus, saw he was normal and then killed him and then found out he was a special
B) Scanned someone else, saw they were normal, and then killed Remus, then found out that their scan was a special after all.

Either way, one of our specials is dead (Remus) or scanned and likely the target tonight. I wouldnt be surprised if they convert the special too. That means we know they could fake that role. If its out Seer thats bad news.

But, now we know about it too. Kudos to tru1cy for being up front about it at least. I know moderating a game can be difficult at times. I think you made the right choice in letting us know.

I realize you are giving us a vote but I think if you really feel the game has been compromised then you have to call it and re-roll. I'm sure that Austin and Chaos will just kill Remus again anyway.

I still think we can get through the game but I will vote re-roll since I think I know how tru1cy feel.

 Re-Roll 
 

[Scoop20906]

Might as well take vote on this. Here is the re-roll vote so far as far as I can tell from reading people's posts:

1. Purge - Re-Roll
2. ChaosRaven - ?
3. Remus West - Re-Roll
4. Unagi - Play on
5. Stessier - ?
6. Scoop20906 - Re-Roll
7. Austin - ?
8. theohall - ?
9. Mipe - ?
10. Mr. Bubbles - ?
11. Lassr - ?
12. Semaj - ?

Re-Roll - 3
Play on - 1

No vote - 8

[stessier]

I'm a re-roller...because that's how I roll. (Sorry, couldn't resist.)

[Lassr]

I was for playing on if it was determined by tru1cy that it didn't really affect the game. I have no inside info to make a vote but I'd hate to have another game end with an asterisk next to the winning team so we may want to re-roll. I'm letting tru1cy decide.

[Remus West]

BTW, I do not think the dead's opinion should count on this as I have a vested interest in one course of action over another

[Unagi]

I was for playing on if it was determined by tru1cy that it didn't really affect the game. I have no inside info to make a vote but I'd hate to have another game end with an asterisk next to the winning team so we may want to re-roll. I'm letting tru1cy decide.

Yeah, I think we are clealy all letting tru1cy decide. My vote wasn't a vote to keep playing even if tru1cy doesn't.

[Scoop20906]

Added a new column

1. Purge - Re-Roll
2. ChaosRaven - ?
3. Remus West - Re-Roll
4. Unagi - Tru1cy Decide
5. Stessier - Re-Roll
6. Scoop20906 - Re-Roll
7. Austin - ?
8. theohall - ?
9. Mipe - ?
10. Mr. Bubbles - ?
11. Lassr - Tru1cy Decide
12. Semaj - ?

Re-Roll - 3
Play on - 0
Tru1cy Decide - 2

No vote - 7

[tru1cy]

I'm with the re-roll. Mainly, cause if I had checked the correct spread sheet then it might have changed the EC's kill order. I'm going to hold off to let a few more chime in, but at this point I think we should start over today.

Again, I apologize for the error, but I want the game to be fair

[stessier]

BTW, I do not think the dead's opinion should count on this as I have a vested interest in one course of action over another

Wouldn't it be great, though, if you came back as a wolf and got your revenge? I mean, who would see that coming??

Tah-dah!

Magically, stessier condemns Remus to a first day lynch and one of today's wolves to an untimely night time death.

[stessier]

It would really be great if you could start over today (if that is the final choice). We should still be able to get in one day before Christmas. That would be swell.

[Mr Bubbles]

well since I haven't been able to follow up until this point I vote reroll. It's early enough along that we should be fine.

[Scoop20906]

1. Purge - Re-Roll
2. ChaosRaven - ?
3. Remus West - Re-Roll
4. Unagi - Tru1cy Decide
5. Stessier - Re-Roll
6. Scoop20906 - Re-Roll
7. Austin - ?
8. theohall - ?
9. Mipe - ?
10. Mr. Bubbles - Re-Roll
11. Lassr - Tru1cy Decide
12. Semaj - ?

Re-Roll - 5
Play on - 0
Tru1cy Decide - 2

[tru1cy]

I'll re-roll at this point. I will not release rolls for this game as I would not want anyone jaded from the previous game and I request that previous special not to reveal any information . Expect new rolls to be sent out by 5 pm est


Again, I apologize for the mistake

[stessier]

I'll re-roll at this point. I will not release rolls for this game as I would not want anyone jaded from the previous game and I request that previous special not to reveal any information.

Spoil sport. I never get to have any fun.

[Remus West]

I live.

for now.

tru1cy, I would suggest a new thread would be best for the reroll game.

[stessier]

tru1cy, I would suggest a new thread would be best for the reroll game.

Naw, just use this one. I promise he won't even have to change the thread title.

[mipe]

It's the baddies gameplay that is now in bad shape because misinformed scan. If the bad guys are OK with this and want to continue -> Continue. If baddies want to reroll -> reroll.

[Unagi]

If Remus got spoiler info - I think we all should.

[Mr Bubbles]

As a side note I was little confused and yes I'm giving my role away.. If you're a norm maybe you could send us a confirmation of our roles whether we are a special or not.

[Scoop20906]

tru1cy, I would suggest a new thread would be best for the reroll game.

Naw, just use this one. I promise he won't even have to change the thread title.

[Semaj]

god damnit

[Unagi]

If Remus got spoiler info - I think we all should.

+1

[Remus West]

If Remus got spoiler info - I think we all should.

+1

You can't +1 yourself. That's cheating.

I did get spoilers BTW so if folks feel they should have them....
I am not going to give them though since tru1cy said he did not want them out. I'll let him if he changes his mind.

[stessier]

If Remus got spoiler info - I think we all should.

+1

You're a very funny guy.

[Unagi]

I just really think that it is more fair for everyone to know, since 1 guy (Remus) knows who everyone was - and it looks like 2 wolf-guys know who 2 other-guys were.

If there is some advantage to knowing. Remus holds the advantage.
If there is some advantage to not knowing, everyone else has something on Remus.
If there isn't an advantage to knowing, what's the harm in sharing.
If there isn't an advantage to not knowing, well - you get the idea...

I think it's 100% right to honor tru1cy's request not to reveal. Absolutely.

I am simply making my plea to tru1cy to change his mind.

[Remus West]

I just really think that it is more fair for everyone to know, since 1 guy (Remus) knows who everyone was - and it looks like 2 wolf-guys know who 2 other-guys were.

If there is some advantage to knowing. Remus holds the advantage.

This is a good thing.

If there is some advantage to not knowing, everyone else has something on Remus.

Screw you, I want in on the ignorance too then damn it.

If there isn't an advantage to knowing, what's the harm in sharing.

What'll ya give me?

If there isn't an advantage to not knowing, well - you get the idea...

Sharing is work though.

I think it's 100% right to honor tru1cy's request not to reveal. Absolutely.

I am simply making my plea to tru1cy to change his mind.

Sure thing. Whiner.

[Chaosraven]

we could simply all agree to lynch Remus Day One... I mean, then at least he got to see the dawn

[purge]

I always found Remus to be a hard read ... Mind you, silent folks are way harder. Remus, he's not so quiet.

Or were you kidding about lynching him?

(posted from an iPhone ... Pls forgive grammar)

[Semaj]

If Remus got spoiler info - I think we all should.

+1

+3

[Semaj]

Double post, rawr

[stessier]

I just really think that it is more fair for everyone to know, since 1 guy (Remus) knows who everyone was - and it looks like 2 wolf-guys know who 2 other-guys were.

If there is some advantage to knowing. Remus holds the advantage.
If there is some advantage to not knowing, everyone else has something on Remus.
If there isn't an advantage to knowing, what's the harm in sharing.
If there isn't an advantage to not knowing, well - you get the idea...

I think it's 100% right to honor tru1cy's request not to reveal. Absolutely.

I am simply making my plea to tru1cy to change his mind.

Huh, you're actually making some sense. Who'd a thunk it.

You've convince me to go from passive ambivalence to active campaigning. Add my voice to those who think we should know the roles.

[purge]

Stess, since Truc1y already indicated the EC's were notified, you might want to check your PM's.



(*that would be Ho Ho Ho*) *cough* *cough*