Unagi wrote:And, to stessier, regarding Qantaga.
1) your huge defense of him created some 'stessier is a bad-guy noise' that was/is hard to see through. (even as 'Stessier=Bad' trying to earn 'Qantaga=Good' trust, or something...) you shouldn't do that.
Why in the world would Q ever trust me for that? I'm not defending him - I'm pointing out all the reasons why it makes no sense that Q is a wolf. A wolf could do that as easily as a human.
2) it's really a mistake to think that an event that led to a player 'gettting out of the noose' actually proves them to be innocent, they could just be wise - and good at this.
It's also illuminating to me how hard you are pushing against this when a perusal of the vote shows how unlikely a Bad Q is.
Code: Select all
Scoop acc Qantaga (1)
[*]tru1cy acc Qantaga (2)
msteelers acc Qantaga (3)
Lassr acc Qantaga (4)
RMC acc Qantaga (5)
Unagi / stessier post at N-1 ... Chaos/Grund/Remus do not
RMC wd Qantaga (4)
Lassr WD Qantaga (3)
Scoop wd Qantaga (2)
msteelers wd Qantaga (1)
Before people started peeling off, we had two unknowns and 1 Baddie on the vote: Scoop, Lassr, RMC
Right now, I know there are 2 Baddies in {Q, Scoop, RMC, Unagi}. If Q is Bad, then there is 1 more in {Scoop, RMC, Unagi}. Lassr was on at N-2 and was not the first to pull his vote off. Hence, Lassr didn't care if Q died. I believe that means Q is either Good or the Zerker as there was absolutely no reason to put the other guy forward that day. If he were the Zerker and Scoop or RMC were his partner, he should have just self voted and ended it. If Unagi was his partner, Unagi had more than enough opportunity to end it. But nothing happened. People peeled off and moved on to the next vote. I just can't believe Q is bad and nothing happens on that vote.
More likely to me is that either all three Baddies were already on it trying to kill a Good Guy, or Unagi didn't want to draw attention to himself as the last vote. And that is the sticking point, because I can see both being the case quite easily.
And, I know this is self serving, but I'm amazed that anyone could re-read this game and think that Lassr and I were on a team. He tried to snare me in a number of stupid things, and I actually pushed back and was willing for it to bite him (example would be his hyper-accusational tone when I mentioned the post that looked like I was 'protected', or when I called him out for pretending there was stuff to 'catch up with'.)
See, that does nothing for me. I could see Lassr making weak attacks that everyone else sees as weak to make his attackee look innocent.
I guess I am not sure what to do with the fact that Lassr put Qantaga to N-1. Sometimes villains do that, and then remove it to 'start a new trend'. Not sure what to say. It's just the only thing that seems to clear him, nothing else really.
N-2, not N-1.
