malchior wrote:
Uh...remote compromise of the system? Do you think we're walking up and yanking cables out? And we could effectively do that anyway with bombs. These guys aren't a tenth the experts we are on communications. Remote compromise of our telecommunications gear is something we deal with all the time (I'm acutely aware of this fwiw). We can shut them down if we want. But we don't because we cut off everyone then. There are political dimensions naturally.
Yes actually. The more I cover the tech involved, the more literally pulling the plug seems to be the mostly likely route to success. I do not share your confidence that the US can just enter and turn off any infrastructure they want when they want to. I admit that I don't feel that war torn Syria would be ready for an e-war, I'm just not sure it's as simple as deciding to do it and then doing it. easy peasy.
If you have personal experience with this, great. I can be dubious of "because I said so" without questioning your professionalism or knowledge, so don't take it personally.
malchior wrote:
Congestion management is generally non-discriminatory - you don't know if your packet will get dropped or not. Sure wait long enough and the message will get out - is it an "effective" and "reliable" means of communication. Not at all. Are their apps timing out due to packet loss? Guess they'll just re-develop them to account for the 90% packet loss, right? There are practical issues that you are likely just unaware of there. Again I think you are looking for perfect jamming when 99+% is well more than good enough. I'm also not suggesting what Trump said is good policy or even desirable but it is definitely possible.
Fair enough. Quality of that communication would inevitably deteriorate. And that might be enough. I'm not going to argue over whether these measures would result in sufficient degradation as to make communication worthless, because I don't know. If we're talking about real time coordinated detonation of multiple payloads, sure. If we're talking about picking up X on the way home from Terrorism class, maybe not. Probably(?) not.
It's true I'm looking for perfect jamming, because 99% jamming means the terrorists are still doing their thing, and if that's the case, what's the point?