Star Wars - Revenge of the Sith - Game Over

[El Guapo]

My confusion is that at N1 we usually give the victim a last say before dropping them. I dont think that happened for scoop.

Also not true. Scoop posted 3 times between the Canadian's vote and my finishing vote.

Yeah, and most importantly Scoop clarified his role (as a regular villager). That's 95% of what we're talking about when we talk about giving someone "a last say" before they get offed - making sure that they don't die without providing their role information to the village.

[Lassr]

Only one option, then. Kill the silence.

may have to, RMC has not placed a vote and is quiet so I will keep my vote there for now.

[Zarathud]

I didn't pay as much attention to the ebb and flow of Day 1 voting. El Guapo is a survivor of the scoop vote.

Let's try this -- assuming the devil is sometimes innocent. Maybe El Guapo was left alive for a reason.

 withdraw Remus West 
 

 accuse Lassr 
 

[Lassr]

My confusion is that at N1 we usually give the victim a last say before dropping them. I dont think that happened for scoop.

Also not true. Scoop posted 3 times between the Canadian's vote and my finishing vote.

Yeah, and most importantly Scoop clarified his role (as a regular villager). That's 95% of what we're talking about when we talk about giving someone "a last say" before they get offed - making sure that they don't die without providing their role information to the village.

Punisher the uninterested villager not even trying to stay up to date or Punisher the wolf knowing he does not have to find wolves...

[El Guapo]

I didn't pay as much attention to the ebb and flow of Day 1 voting. El Guapo is a survivor of the scoop vote.

Let's try this -- assuming the devil is sometimes innocent. Maybe El Guapo was left alive for a reason.

 withdraw Remus West 
 

 accuse Lassr 
 

GOD HAS A PLAN FOR ME.

[Lassr]

I didn't pay as much attention to the ebb and flow of Day 1 voting. El Guapo is a survivor of the scoop vote.

Let's try this -- assuming the devil is sometimes innocent. Maybe El Guapo was left alive for a reason.

 withdraw Remus West 
 

 accuse Lassr 
 

GOD HAS A PLAN FOR ME.

but which God?

[El Guapo]

I didn't pay as much attention to the ebb and flow of Day 1 voting. El Guapo is a survivor of the scoop vote.

Let's try this -- assuming the devil is sometimes innocent. Maybe El Guapo was left alive for a reason.

 withdraw Remus West 
 

 accuse Lassr 
 

GOD HAS A PLAN FOR ME.

but which God?

Pan, the goat god.

[Remus West]

Unagi, I absolutely shared my thinking on you day 1 to see how folks reacted to it. I wanted to see what people thought about that line of thinking and how they reacted to it. I do not feel I pushed for folks to lynch you day 1 at all. I shared a line of thinking and tried to spur some conversation about it in order to avoid the completely random day 1 lynch that leaves us with just as little to go on day 2.

Day 2 you came out firing at me for living based off the idea I would have left you alive were I a wolf. Discounting the possibility of your being protected entirely in spite of my having mentioned it on day 1. How is that not weird? You view yourself as such a threat to team bad guy that you can not imagine NOT being the target for night kill but of such low value to team good guy that you can not imagine being the target of the protector? The two concepts fail to mesh.

[Remus West]

Also, commenting that you do not feel compelled to comment doesn't do it for me so my vote stays where it is.

[Punisher]

My confusion is that at N1 we usually give the victim a last say before dropping them. I dont think that happened for scoop.

Also not true. Scoop posted 3 times between the Canadian's vote and my finishing vote.

OK. I just re-read the thread and you are correct sir. I'm not sure why I thought Vorret scooped him (and no it's not because I'm a wolf)

[Punisher]

My confusion is that at N1 we usually give the victim a last say before dropping them. I dont think that happened for scoop.

Also not true. Scoop posted 3 times between the Canadian's vote and my finishing vote.

Yeah, and most importantly Scoop clarified his role (as a regular villager). That's 95% of what we're talking about when we talk about giving someone "a last say" before they get offed - making sure that they don't die without providing their role information to the village.

No need to repeat yourself, I already replied to your first post.

[Punisher]

My confusion is that at N1 we usually give the victim a last say before dropping them. I dont think that happened for scoop.

Also not true. Scoop posted 3 times between the Canadian's vote and my finishing vote.

Yeah, and most importantly Scoop clarified his role (as a regular villager). That's 95% of what we're talking about when we talk about giving someone "a last say" before they get offed - making sure that they don't die without providing their role information to the village.

Punisher the uninterested villager not even trying to stay up to date or Punisher the wolf knowing he does not have to find wolves...

Punisher the interested villager who screwed up.

[El Guapo]

My confusion is that at N1 we usually give the victim a last say before dropping them. I dont think that happened for scoop.

Also not true. Scoop posted 3 times between the Canadian's vote and my finishing vote.

OK. I just re-read the thread and you are correct sir. I'm not sure why I thought Vorret scooped him (and no it's not because I'm a wolf)

So it's because of some reason unrelated to your being a wolf?

[Punisher]

My confusion is that at N1 we usually give the victim a last say before dropping them. I dont think that happened for scoop.

Also not true. Scoop posted 3 times between the Canadian's vote and my finishing vote.

OK. I just re-read the thread and you are correct sir. I'm not sure why I thought Vorret scooped him (and no it's not because I'm a wolf)

So it's because of some reason unrelated to your being a wolf?

I see what you did there...
and yes its unrelated to my being a wolf because I am not a wolf, so since I am not a wolf (or a Sith), it is unrelated to that.

[Moliere]

and yes its unrelated to my being a wolf because I am not a wolf, so since I am not a wolf (or a Sith), it is unrelated to that.

So, yes you're not saying that it has nothing to do with you not being a wolf, right? Sounds suspicious to me.

[Punisher]

and yes its unrelated to my being a wolf because I am not a wolf, so since I am not a wolf (or a Sith), it is unrelated to that.

So, yes you're not saying that it has nothing to do with you not being a wolf, right? Sounds suspicious to me.

42

[Moliere]

Good movie.

[RMC]

I have been sitting back and reading, and poking fun this whole game. I think that this is one of those slow burns, as we don't have any newbies per se.

The first few games you play you are all right up in people's grills and defending yourself, or outing yourself. This game started and the non-wolf's are already looking around at everyone, and the wolves are looking at each other, and realize that one misstep puts them 50% of the way to losing.

So I think this game will be very slow, and people will be posting less.

With that said, I guess we can't leave space for people to hide in the silence, so Remus West is right on that account.

My top three guesses are:

El Guapo
Remus West

And an outside shot would be : Zarathud

I am not sure on any of those, it's all gut. I think Remus is playing his helpful self, trying to become the leader to get us to lynch people while secretly laughing at us as we are manipulated.

El Guapo is just because, he is usually more animated overall. But then again, I thought Scoop was off.

[Punisher]

I have been sitting back and reading, and poking fun this whole game. I think that this is one of those slow burns, as we don't have any newbies per se.

The first few games you play you are all right up in people's grills and defending yourself, or outing yourself. This game started and the non-wolf's are already looking around at everyone, and the wolves are looking at each other, and realize that one misstep puts them 50% of the way to losing.

So I think this game will be very slow, and people will be posting less.

With that said, I guess we can't leave space for people to hide in the silence, so Remus West is right on that account.

My top three guesses are:

El Guapo
Remus West

And an outside shot would be : Zarathud

I am not sure on any of those, it's all gut. I think Remus is playing his helpful self, trying to become the leader to get us to lynch people while secretly laughing at us as we are manipulated.

El Guapo is just because, he is usually more animated overall. But then again, I thought Scoop was off.

In your defense, Scoop is always off..

[Lassr]

a burst of activity!

Still seen nothing to change my vote from RMC for now, but the deadline approaches and we cannot waste a day without hunting wolves so someone needs to go.

[Holman]

Ugh. This is going to come down to a deadline rush, isn't it?

[Zarathud]

Not if the rest of you get it together and vote, or at least declare your intentions.

[Moliere]

 Moliere 
 

 withdraw Zaracastle 
 


 Unagi 
 

[Unagi]

 El Guapo 
 


my thought / musings...

Zarathud (/Newcastle) is one thought I have also... but not sure. I would have expected Newcastle to chime in on Remus' claim on me, but he never did. And I think he posted during it all. If Remus is a senator/villager - then I could see a Newcastle/Wolf wanting Remus and I both to just go at it. I could also see Zarathud, after taking the reins, voting against Remus... just one of a few theories.

El Guapo, cause I think he's participating but just playfully - which is his style, but there is some depth of commentary that I'm not hearing from him. Also, I think he's a strong player and perhaps a good 'partner pick' of an alpha.

Moliere is clearly paying attention as his correction to Punisher showed, and I'm not used to him calling other players out on their mistakes and mischaracterization of the game's proceedings. Honestly sounded like he was involved in this game much more than he is really showing. /shrug.

Punisher... His 'villager not paying attention' moment did certain have that certain feel to it. Red Herring? not sure.

Lassr - keeps his mostly 'for no reason' vote on RMC - but I'm sure he's tempted to vote many other places... but sticks to RMC.... no clue if it's meaningful. Just noting it. He's a slick MF.

RMC - seems pretty 'jolly'. I do think he likes the wolf role and has fun with it.

Remus - spoken of my distrust of his play... which amounted to "why is Unagi still alive?" - planted on Day 0.

Holman - I don't like how willing he is to 'convict me' on Day 1. I don't mind him thinking I may be a wolf, but I'd think he'd wait a little more than basically 1 night... (not that I think I should be lynched tomorrow, but that should be perhaps when the Seer can step up and guide us a little).


Wow. There are Not a lot of us. I wonder if the Seer has anything if maybe even today is a good day to step up?

Thoughts?

[El Guapo]

For what it's worth this *is* my normal werewolf playing pattern. Day 1 I make a lot of jokes while voting more or less randomly and trying to stir shit up. Day 2 I go mostly quiet because there's some information but still not really enough to know what I'm doing, and then the thread builds up, and I'm like ugh, let's do something else today. Then day 3 my guilt gets the better of me and I'm like, "ugh, fine, let's read through the thread again and see what we find." And then I wind up voting for the protector or something like that.

[El Guapo]

FWIW right now I still feel ok with my vote for RMC. Mostly quiet and popping up when prodded...feels a little bit like he's trying to stay under the radar. Though honestly, I'm still not sure how to best suss out who's playing under the radar because they're a wolf trying to hide and who is because they're a special trying to hide.

[Unagi]

hmm. OK.

For what it's worth, does anyone want to join me here on this El Guapo thing?

[bb2112]

Day 2 Votes

1. El Guapo --------> RMC
2. Moliere ----------> Zarathud, Unagi
3. Remus West ---> Unagi, Punisher
4. RMC -------------->
5. Zaracastle -------> RMC, Remus West, Lassr
6. Holman ----------> Unagi
7. Punisher --------->
8. Lassr -------------> RMC
9. Unagi ------------> Remus West, Moliere, El Guapo


Votes:
2 RMC ----------------> Lassr, El Guapo
2 Unagi --------------> Holman, Moliere
1 Punisher -----------> Remus West
1 El Guapo -----------> Unagi
1 Lassr ----------------> Zarathud


5 Votes Needed

Dead:
Isgrimnur
Chaosraven
Newthud
Grundbegriff
Stessier
Lord Mortis
Revhempus
Archinerd
Purge
Semaj
Tru1cy
Lagom Lite
Triggercut
Theohall
Pr0ner
Mr. Bubbles
Coopasonic
Austin
Redrun
Patriots
Scoop20906 - T-Balled
Vorret - Looking Around

Deadline:
Deadline: Friday February 16th, 9PM

[Moliere]

For what it's worth, does anyone want to join me here on this El Guapo thing?

I will have to pass since self-lynching is usually frowned upon in these games.

[Lassr]

List of suspects that have my interest.
RMC-obviously. His voting for Remus after I remind him he usually votes for Remus and his joke about resembling a remark about him being the devil. Like Unagi said, I think he enjoys being a wolf and he may be playing with us with his joking style.
Remus/Unagi-I don't think both are wolves, that back and forth does not appear contrived but one could be.
Then the quieter players (Zarathud, Holman, Punisher)-one of which could be the wolf seer lying low...

[Unagi]

El G is not at all catching your eye then?

[Lassr]

El G is not at all catching your eye then?

not at the moment. He would probably me mid-list for me simply because I'd pick him as wolf if I could choose. If he is off then you may be more attuned to his playing style than I.

[Remus West]

Remus - spoken of my distrust of his play... which amounted to "why is Unagi still alive?" - planted on Day 0.

Oh for the love of Pete! Did you even read what I wrote? To me you being alive right now has ZERO to do with your role. If you are a bad guy then, duh. If you are a good guy then I doubt they target you for fear of protection.

This misrepresentation of what I'm saying combined with coming out gunning for me at dawn today is why I doubt you are a good guy. Neither of those things are typical of you. Disagree with me? Nearly always. Misrepresent repeatedly? Not in my memory.

[Remus West]

hmm. OK.

For what it's worth, does anyone want to join me here on this El Guapo thing?

I could happily lynch El Guapo if it were not you pushing it. Although, combined with some of your statements I'm actively considering it in spite of myself.

[RMC]

Remus - spoken of my distrust of his play... which amounted to "why is Unagi still alive?" - planted on Day 0.

Oh for the love of Pete! Did you even read what I wrote? To me you being alive right now has ZERO to do with your role. If you are a bad guy then, duh. If you are a good guy then I doubt they target you for fear of protection.

This misrepresentation of what I'm saying combined with coming out gunning for me at dawn today is why I doubt you are a good guy. Neither of those things are typical of you. Disagree with me? Nearly always. Misrepresent repeatedly? Not in my memory.

I know I am on some people's radar. But Unagi does have a point about this.

[Unagi]

Remus - spoken of my distrust of his play... which amounted to "why is Unagi still alive?" - planted on Day 0.

Oh for the love of Pete! Did you even read what I wrote? To me you being alive right now has ZERO to do with your role. If you are a bad guy then, duh. If you are a good guy then I doubt they target you for fear of protection.

This misrepresentation of what I'm saying combined with coming out gunning for me at dawn today is why I doubt you are a good guy. Neither of those things are typical of you. Disagree with me? Nearly always. Misrepresent repeatedly? Not in my memory.

I read what you wrote - but you framed it under the package of why I was most likely chosen by the Alpha.

If the alpha felt the need to keep me off his case, wouldn't he just kill me tonight instead of making me his partner?

Tonight you may be protected.

My reply to that :

Your premise that I would likely be protected on Night 0 is not something I think you really believe. I don't think I've EVER been protected in that manner. Not once.

Again: No one has ever just randomly protected me on the very first Night EVER - not once. Above, you pretty much hang the whole "why don't they just kill me, if they fear me so much" counter-argument on the 'Oh, it's the fear that you are protected!". It's an absurd and strung-out theory...

(Found this gem while looking for some of the above quotes)
Listen to you here trying to work everyone against me: (it's actually kinda funny)

<snip>
...after he spent yesterday down playing what a potential threat he is but then he comes out saying that only I would have the guts to let him live implying the rest of you are so scared of him you wouldn't allow him to see the day?

lol.

"You guys hear that !? Unagi just called you guys sissies!!!"


 Remus 
 

[Holman]

Holman - I don't like how willing he is to 'convict me' on Day 1. I don't mind him thinking I may be a wolf, but I'd think he'd wait a little more than basically 1 night... (not that I think I should be lynched tomorrow, but that should be perhaps when the Seer can step up and guide us a little).

OK, this is just weird.

First of all, I didn't even vote for you on Day 1. I voted for Remus.

I voted for you today (Day 2) because you're playing aggressively and reacted weirdly to morning events.

Second, I've never "convicted you" of anything. I've already made clear that I'm not 100% on anyone, but you're the player who has most tripped my radar.

You're characterizing the village very inaccurately and loosely, I must say.

[Zarathud]

That's not as wild of a mischaracterization as Lassr saying I'm one of the quiet ones.

Unagi is reaching pretty far saying Newcastle was suspicious for not being active or ignoring that I actually *did* vote on Remus. Whatever's going on between Unagi and Remus requires a small room and a rubber object. But with Unagi and Remus both acting strange, they're either genuinely pissed at each other (likely) or both wolves kicking up smoke (possible).

My guess is still between El Guapo and Lassr based on yesterday's votes. With the push on El Guapo, I'm staying with Lassr for now.

Voting for RMC or Moliere would just be too easy, so I'm not going there yet.

Holman or Punisher could get my "kill the silence" vote, almost a toss up.

[Holman]

That's not as wild of a mischaracterization as Lassr saying I'm one of the quiet ones.

[...]

Holman or Punisher could get my "kill the silence" vote, almost a toss up.

[Punisher]

Holman or Punisher could get my "kill the silence" vote, almost a toss up.

So... If you are very active you might be called aggressive and wolf..
If you are "quiet" It's kill the silent ones..

My question...Has anyone figured out the ideal post count to stay in the "safe" zone?
Is it post count or word count? Is it a combination of both?
Does it require attacking or defending any particular person? (Except for Vorret since being Canadian means he's up to no good..Hovering over us in the US like a peeping tom.. I see you vorret, I see you..) (Side bar.. If he moves to the US does it change anything or once a Canadian, always a Canadian? Are you even allowed to move here from Canada? Wouldn't the extreme temperature change be fatal or do you just slowly move south once a year)

Anyway enough rambling... I typicality like just sitting back and listening to gather my thoughts and post when I think I have something to contribute. For day one, I mostly just like to watch the drama because I don't think anything on Day 1 is enough to make a good decision.(Has there ever been a day 1 wolf kill by the way? If so, was it luck or was it something the wolf did to trip themselves up?)

As for this round, I am thinking Remus or Unagi or both may be wolves because the "fighting" seems a little too much right now. I may wait until the last minute to vote to see if either one clicks in my head (or someone else depending on the chatter)