Alefroth wrote: Tue Jul 18, 2023 2:41 pm
Like these criteria?
The study measures quality of life issues including crime, health care, childcare and health care, as well as inclusive policies on discrimination and reproductive rights.
Exactly. The study itself admitted that people are rapidly moving into some of these states, like Texas, Tennessee and Florida (though I think Florida's days as a boom state are about to end.) In fact, the only state on that list that I'm aware of people leaving in large numbers is Indiana. Furthermore, I've never heard of anyone using those criteria as the reason to move or not move to a state. People are far more likely to use criteria like weather, cost of living, availability of jobs, availability of affordable housing, clean air, etc. and in those areas most of these states excel. Finally, the concerns you listed are overblown, IMHO.
Let's look at my state, Alabama. Childcare in Alabama, for example, is very easy and cheap to find. Most churches here also run daycares at a very reasonable price (and no, they didn't manage to indoctrinate this atheist) even in small rural towns. Healthcare is easy to access and much cheaper than in Blue states as well. In my state, for example, we have a world-class hospital that is also the 8th largest in the nation, last I checked (can't speak for those who live in isolated small towns though). We're also a very diverse state (except for Asians, but we all know that they don't count
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f088b/f088b1ce865ef3c355859c67bfa93f7521cfa2c2" alt="Rolling Eyes :roll:"
), and I am not aware of any issues with discrimination whatsoever. (I clearly remember that during the small Birmingham Black LIves Matter protests the protestors were almost entirely white and every one of the cops standing by and rolling their eyes were black.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f68ab/f68ab6254633b5e9d561945374a5880ee64d256d" alt="Mr. Green :mrgreen:"
) Sure, we have racists but the ones I knew in upstate NY and Conn. were actually much angrier and outspoken than the ones I run into here. In truth, most of the Black people I know and work with are conservative to moderate on social issues and don't see any problems with race relations, even those who recently moved here from Blue states (and there are a lot of those). Even in a small town like mine nearly half my co-workers are openly gay or lesbian and no one cares (I've only worked with one Transgender person, however, and I do suspect they will face some hostility in small rural towns especially). While we do have a six week ban on abortion, you can still use abortion pills and this only applies to young women who are pregnant and don't want to keep the child so it's not a problem for most anyway (but, yes, it still pisses me off tremendously
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/16afc/16afcea8e0ed449bbdb54b2d4e04e1186d272545" alt="Evil or Very Mad :evil:"
). The only thing you listed that I do think is a concern is crime, but as one who lived nearly a decade in downtown Birmingham, I can tell you that almost all of the crime is concentrated in poor, inner-city, minority neighborhoods, which is a problem all over the nation. I never felt safe after dark in Albany, New Haven, etc. but I often walked the streets of Birmingham after dark with zero concern.
That's NOT to say that Alabama is a Paradise. The state government is very conservative, though our current Governor is a big improvement over what we traditionally get here, and hasn't tried to grandstand on divisive issues unlike most of her predecessors. Funding for schools in rural counties is very deficient. And while people here are very friendly, they generally have what I consider to be backward views on most social issues which can be a problem if you are a very progressive thinker and live outside of Birmingham, Huntsville or a college town. Some of our laws are irresponsible, such as allowing anyone to carry a concealed weapon with no permit and the lack of vehicle inspections of any kind, but overall I would say that the lack of Government overreach is a virtue of the Deep South when compared to most Blue States (where it can be a Felony to not use a Transgender persons preferred pronouns, or being unable to drive my car to work because I failed an emissions inspection.) And public transportation? LOL! Living in the city and riding a bus, or constantly using Uber or a taxi if you live near a city, are about your only options. Our low taxes and low cost of living do come at a price.
TLDR: While I agree that the states on this list have real issues, I think the list was carefully crafted to leave out the things most people look at when moving to a new state and substituted items which would mostly be of concern to a progressive thinker. Furthermore, it seems to think that if local governments aren't providing or subsidizing a service (like child care) that it is not available at a reasonable price, which is incorrect.