The Trader Feedback List

[LucidSmoke]

Ragnarok gets a +1 for a quick delivery from Canada.

[Ralph-Wiggum]

+1 to Grundbegriff for a very quick and easy trade.

[Vinda-Lou]

+1 to Gwog. Thanks for a great trade. Would trade again.

[rob]

+1 to lokiju.

[Ragnarok]

+1 to LucidSmoke. Great trader, good communication. Thanks!

[Ralph-Wiggum]

+1 to hitbyambulance for managing the quickest shipping I've ever seen (WA to NC in two days!).

[Veloxi]

+1 for quantum for getting Warlords Battlecry: III.

[Grundbegriff]

Since it appears that the trader feedback tally hasn't been updated since 18 Oct 2004, I've taken the liberty of saving Blackhawk some scutwork.

If you've changed nicks since the last update, I may not have noticed. If you find that you have two listings that ought to be consolidated, let me know.

On occasions (three of them, I think) where someone asked that Bubba Sue be given a +2 instead of a +1 or asked that +1 go not only to the other trader but also to some überkewl third party not directly involved in the transaction, I've ignored the request.

Kudos to Austin and Windows95 for graduating into the enviably '1337 ranks of the Spectacular Tentacular Traders™!

Hesitant to trade? Please note that this set of data represents 6,946 expressions of customer satisfaction and only 29 failures. That's a success rate of 99.58%!

Here's some boilerplate:

Welcome to The Trader Feedback List. Please read the following before posting:

• (+#) denotes the number of positive trade experiences.
• (-#) denotes the number of negative trade experiences.
• Along with your comments, please rate your completed trade experience. Be sure to include the EXACT forum name of the trader and to state whether that trader should receive a +1 or a -1.
• Rate the trader based on each individual trade experience, not on each item in a particular transaction.
• If you are giving several people feedback within a single post, please include each person on a separate line or in a separate paragraph.
• If you give multiple +1s to a single person for multiple transactions, please clarify in your post that that's what you're doing. Otherwise, anything above +1 will be ignored.
• Please use this thread only to provide feedback about trades, purchases, PIFFs, and similar transactions. If you need to discuss something with another trader, please do so via e-mail or PM.

Sucking Undertow Traders (Traders who have at least |3| negative feedback -- watch your step!)

• bplotkin
• Kelric Varchilde
• TSS

Spectacular Tentacular Traders (Traders who have at least |10| positive feedback):

• Ace of Spades
• Aewulf
• akerr
• Al
• Alefroth
• Andy
• Andy22
• angrycoder
• AOE
• ArmyOfOne
• ATB
• Austin
• Bad_Demographic
• Baron Of Hell
• bcr19374
• bdw418
• Big Jake
• BlackBerry
• Blackhawk
• Blackwulf
• Blonco
• BobM
• Boudreaux
• Bushido32
• Buster Poindexter
• Carentan
• Chemical Agent
• Chris Grenard
• Chris Gwinn
• Clearcut
• cow_cookie
• Curtis
• da_toad
• Damian
• Darkhugh
• Darkside Blue
• Darksoul
• Dave Fisher
• deadzone
• Devilman
• dobberhd
• Drazzil
• durwoodx
• EduardoX
• el producto
• Eliot
• ericb
• evilekim
• ExRod
• f_monster
• Falcon554
• Farleybarnstorm
• FishBulb
• Fizban
• freyland
• Fubeca
• Gedd
• Geezer
• gellar
• Glycerine_74
• godhugh
• Godzilla Blitz
• godzy
• Goldchamp
• Goldenember
• Gollum
• Goonch
• gorham09
• Graham
• Gratch
• greeneggs-n-ham
• Grundbegriff
• Gumps
• Hamlet3145
• haplo1
• helot2000
• hitbyambulance
• Hrothgar
• Ibby
• IBDoomed
• igbe
• ImWatchingYou
• Incendiary Lemon
• InfiniteStill
• infoghost
• Inverarity
• Jament
• Jancelot
• jblank
• Jeff Jones
• Jeff Nyman
• Jeffery Lamarche
• Jeremy
• JetFred
• JMDiller
• joeyjazz
• John Christian
• Jorton
• JR
• JSHAW
• Jumangi
• junkie
• Kaigen
• karapcik
• kathode
• Kehama
• Kelric Varchilde
• KernelVenus
• Kestrel
• KiloOhm
• Knavery
• Kratzer
• LanceM
• Lawbeefaroni
• lildrgn
• lokiju
• Lord Corwin
• -Lord Ebonstone-
• Lordman
• mad_alien
• Magicboy
• MaxZero
• Mersault
• MikeToth
• MLAW
• Mooncalf
• MrBad
• mrgauth
• msduncan
• naednek
• namretaw
• Nan_Desu
• Nine
• noun
• optic_freeze
• Orpheo
• Papageno
• Paul Roberts
• Paulbot
• philm
• phormio
• Poomba
• Qbe
• Redfive
• Rincewind
• Rob_Merritt
• ROTC1983
• Rowan
• rslifka
• Sam Hell
• sanjuro
• scraper
• Serlesh
• setaside
• SG-1
• Shazbot
• Siljanus
• Simon
• slackerjoe
• slambie
• slobro
• Speaker2Animals
• spigot
• St_Dysan
• stolazi
• Sudy Nym
• swhitecr
• Szgany
• TebunkerTheNextGeneration
• The Meal
• The_Man
• tiktokman
• Tim Maynard
• toonces
• Torfish
• TradeAble
• trav
• tripcrow
• tru1cy
• trueheart78
• Two_Sheds
• VegasD
• Vinda-Lou
• VT
• Warning
• Whiteboyskim
• Windows95
• Wookiee007
• xenocide
• x-eyed|mary
• XMANN
• YellowKing
• Zarkon
• zekester
• Zero
• Zoyd

Here are the facts:
#
13devils (+4)
3-2 Count (+7)
9-ball (+2)

A
Aaron Conklin (+1)
Accidental Design (+5)
Ace of Spades (+18)
Aenima (+7)
Aewulf (+25)
Agent (+3)
AgtFox (+1)
AHardPlace (+3)
Aidanius (+7)
akerr (+14)
Al (+12)
aledromo (+3)
Alefroth (+33)
Alex2 (+2)
alienhead_69 (+5)
an0nym0us b0sch (+1)
Andrew J. Mallon (+7)
Andrew Wonser (+3)
Andy (+14)
Andy M (+1)
Andy Redbeard (+1)
Andy22 (+20)
angrycoder (+24)
Animal114 (+3)
Annukin (+2)
AOE (+12)
Appaz Knarf (+5)
ArchimedesV (+1)
ArmyOfOne (+17)
arniswon (+4)
Ascendent (+3)
ATB (+27)
Athelbrose (+1)
Austen (+2)
Austin (+14)
Avenger (+3)
avid_gamer (+1)
Azih (+2)
Azrs (+6)

B
B Dog (+7)
Bad_Demographic (+12)
Bakhtosh Redclaw (+6)
Baron Of Hell (+10)
bcr19374 (+50)
bdw418 (+11)
Beowulf (+1)
Big Jake (+31)
bigearv14 (+6)
Biggercup (+2)
BigV (+1)
Billins (+4)
Binky (+3)
BlackBerry (+27)
Blackhawk (+104)
Blackwulf (+33)
Bladecloud (+2)
Blaise (+1)
Blonco (+13)
BobM (+28)
Boo Radley (+4)
Boudreaux (+40)
Boxcar (+7)
bplotkin (+9) (-4)
Brettmc (+7)
BrewersDroop (+1)
Brian Evans (+4) (-2)
brotheroftruth (+5)
Bruin_2k (+2)
bsouthard (+3)
Bubbles (+1)
Bug (+1)
bugeyez (+1)
Burnout (+1)
Bushido32 (+16)
Buster Poindexter (+27)
Byrns (+7)

C
Calipfso (+1)
Canex (+1)
Canuck (+2)
Captain Caveman (+2)
Carentan (+41)
CelicaKydd (+3)
Certis (+1)
ChaoZ (+5)
CharlieDelta (+5)
CharredBronson (+4)
Chaz (+5)
Chemical Agent (+20)
chicagochris (+1)
Chris Grenard (+74)
Chris Gwinn (+23)
Chris Johnson (+3)
Chronic (+1)
Clanwulfmember (+1)
Claudius Pompeianus (+1)
Clearcut (+13)
Coachman (+1)
Colonel Turbine (+2)
ComatoseTiger (+1)
connus (+2)
consolz (+1)
controlguy (+1)
coopasonic (+6)
Cortilian (+4)

cow_cookie (+15)
CrashTest (+7)
CRAZY (+1)

Crazyhorse (+2) (-1)
croman (+4)
Crowley (+4)
Crumsteel (+8)
Crux (+1)
CSL (+1)
Curtis (+20)

D
da_toad (+12)
Daddy-O (+1)
Daehawk (+3)
Damian (+13)
dandylife (+1)
DangerBalls (+6)
Dark~Vulgar (+3)
darkbluejedi (+7)
Darkfyre (+1)
Darkhugh (+14)
Darkside Blue (+22) (-1)
Darksoul (+35)
DAS (+1)
daszo24 (+1)
Dave Fisher (+11)
Dave so (+5)
Daveman (+7)
David Roberts (+3)
davidbld (+1)
dbt1949 (+6)
DD (+8)
Dead Ben (+2)
Dead_Meat (+1)
deadzone (+35)
DeFault the Unremarkable (+8)
Depward (+3)
detourm (+3)
Devilman (+15)
Dewey's Monster (+1)
dinkytoy (+1)
Dirt (+1)
disarm (+4)
dkass (+2)
dobberhd (+19)
DocDarm (+2)
Doink (+3)
Doomboy (+9)
Doug Robinson (+1)
DougA (+2)
DPW (+2)
Draco (+2)
DragonFyre (+4)
Drazzil (+34)
Dreborn (+1)
Drifter (+3)
Driver (+6)
DrJones (+5)
Drumfire (+1)
durwoodx (+22)

E
EBatemann (+1)
Ecologic (+2)
EduardoX (+12)
Eel Snave (+2)
Eightball (+7)
el producto (+14)
Elementary (+1)
Eliot (+121)
Ender21 (+1)
Engine#9 (+1)
Enigma (+2)
ericb (+37)
erisquilty (+2)
esofad@work (+1)
Essate (+1)
eton (+2)
EvilAvatar (+2)
evilekim (+44)
EvilHomer3K (+5)
Exodor (+3)
ExRod (+18)

F
f_monster (+29)
Fafhrd (+7)
Fake Dude (+1)
Falcon554 (+19)
Faolin (+1)
Farleybarnstorm (+21)
Fishbelly (+6)
FishBulb (+23)
Fizban (+17)
Flag_QB (+6)
Forbidden Donut (+1)
Formix (+1)
fragasm (+1)
Frankenstein (+1)
Freezer-TPF- (+5)
freyland (+58)
Frost (+5)
Frost716 (+2)
Frozen Devil (+1)
FTRracer (+2)
Fubeca (+11)

G
gbasden (+1)
Gedd (+17)
Geezer (+12)
gellar (+18)
George (+5)
GG(Ket) (+1)
giantsfan (+4)
Glycerine_74 (+22)
godhugh (+21)
Godzilla (+1)
Godzilla Blitz (+27)
godzy (+11)
Goldchamp (+65)
Goldenember (+15)
Gollum (+10)
goo2 (+3)
Gookie_Monster (-1)
Goonch (+19)
gorham09 (+17)
Graham (+46)
Gratch (+36)
Greedo (+9)
greeneggs-n-ham (+15)
Greybeard (+4)
Grievous Angel (+7)
Grifman (+2)
Grundbegriff (+69)
gt_steve (+1)
Guildboss (+2)
Gumps (+13)
Gwen (+2)
Gwog (+3)
gx5ilver (+1)

H
Hamlet3145 (+12)
haplo1 (+38)
Hazzen (+1)
hcajandig (+2)
Head (+1)
helot2000 (+14)
Hendo (+2)
Hentzau (+1)
Hetz (+4)
HighTimber (+2)
hipolito (+2)
HispanicGamer (+3)
hitbyambulance (+22)
hodge313 (+4)
hooraj (+1)
House (+3)
howie549 (+2)
Howitzer (+3)
Hrothgar (+29)
Hunter (+3)

I
Ibby (+16)
IBDoomed (+14)
igbe (+24)
Iggy (+5)
Ignis Fatuus (+3)
IHateMorrowind (+0)(-1)
ImLawBoy (+4)
Impervious (+1)
ImWatchingYou (+16)
Incendiary Lemon (+10)
InfiniteStill (+15)
infoghost (+21)
intangbl (+3)
Inverarity (+30)
IronWulf(+4)
isgrb (+7)
ISMODRED (+1)

J
jadedcritic (+4)
Jago (+1)
Jament (+37)
James Warden (+1)
Jancelot (+17)
jaskerr (+1)
Jason (+2)
Jason Brown (+2)
Jaymann (+1)
jblank (+61)
JCC (+1)
Jebsi (+1)
Jeff Jones (+24)
Jeff Nyman (+15)
Jeffery Lamarche (+37)
Jelry (+1)
Jeremy (+16)
jessie (+3)
JetFred (+100)
JiffyPeanutButter (+4)
jimbo (+1)
JJDyn0mite (+6)
jkinross (+1)
JMDiller (+44)
Joe Newell (+1)
Joel Mathis (+1)
joeyjazz (+66)
John Christian (+14)
JonOss (+1)
Jorton (+12)
Josh (+2)
jpinard (+7)
JR (+16)
js (+1)
JSHAW (+95)
JT47319 (+9)
juji (+4)
Jumangi (+24)
junior375 (+5)
junkie (+29)
JXPrime (+1)

K
Kaddish (-1)
Kadoth Nodens (+1)
Kaigen (+98)
Kalar (+1)
karapcik (+72)
Kasey Chang (+5)
kathode (+17)
KC (+1)
KCJay (+1)
Kehama (+15)
Kelric Varchilde (+26) (-4)
KernelVenus (+11)
Kestrel (+28)
killer_roach (+1)
KiloOhm (+24)
kmmckenz (+1)
Knavery (+24)
Knightshade Dragon (+5)
Koz (+3)
Kratz (+1)
Kratzer (+59)
KrispyKremer (+2)
Krusader (+2)

L
LanceM (+14)
Laner (+3)
Lassr (+4)
Laura (+1)
Lawbeefaroni (+13)
leaf_fan00 (+1)
Lebo (+5)
leo8877 (+1)
lildrgn (+13)
linszoid (+4)
LiquidBronze1 (+1)
Literatii (+1)
Little Fancy Pants (+1)
Locnar (+3)
lokiju (+60)
Lord Corwin (+18)
-Lord Ebonstone- (128)
Lordman (+10)
Low Rent (+6)
Lower (+2)
LucidSmoke (+7)
Lyno (+9)

M
mad_alien (+29)
madpeon (+1)
Magic (+3)
Magicboy (+11)
Magnetik (+3)
Mahogeny (+1)
Malichai11 (+1)
Malificent (+8)
Maneesh (+2)
Marcain (+2)
Marik (+2)
Mark Asher (+1)
Markly (+1)
Matrix (+5)
Matthew Rorie (+3)
Mattsflask (+4)
mavman (+1)
MaxZero (+33)
mb737 (+2)
McBain (+1)
Mcloud 10 (+1)
me (+1)
Mersault (+12)
Metalhed (+8)
MHS (+2)
mier (+1)
MikeR8 (+2)
MikeToth (+48)
mikshan (+1)
MLAW (+10)
mmandell (+8)
moghedian (+2)
Monk (+1)
Montag (+2)
moogen (+7)
Mookee (+6)
Mooncalf (+16)
mori (+1)
Mortanius (+5) (-1)
Mowbray6 (+1)
MrBad (+29)
mrgauth (+51)
msduncan (+10)
Mudfrost (+1)
Mustang66 (+3)
mx1mx1 (+2)
Mycroft (+5)
Mystic95Z (+9)
Mytocles (+1)

N
naednek (+71)
namatoki (+9)
namretaw (+15)
Nan_Desu (+19)
Ned Flanders (+5)
Neuro (+1)
Nile (+5)
Nine (+13)
Nixon (+1)
noun (+54)
Nox (+4)
nVidiot (-1)
Nydrax (+2)
Nymann (+2)

O
Odious (+1)
Olaf (+2)
optic_freeze (+50)
Orpheo (+38)
Owain (+2)

P
Papageno (+11)
Papashango (+2)
Paul G (+1)
Paul Roberts (+19)
Paulbaxter (+1)
Paulbot (+12)
Peacedog (+1)
peace-man (+1)
philm (+36)
philosophist (+3)
phishbate (+1)
phormio (+67)
Pi (+1)
Pinky1234567890 (+1)
pipboy (+3)
plasticninjaturtle (+4)
Pointer (+2)
Poomba (+21)
Psilus (+9)

Q
Q (+5)
Qbe (+21)
quantum (+1)
Quickfics (+2)
qwartok (+2)
qwoozy (+2)

R
Rage (+1)
Ragnarok (+4)
Raith (+6)
Raith95 (+1)
Ralph-Wiggum (+8)
Raven (+2)
Raven VII (+5)
Raven_13 (+4)
Ravenlock (+1)
Red (+1)
Redfive (+17)
rhett (+1)
Rich in KCK (+1)
Rich LaPorte (+3)
Rincewind (+78) (-2)
Rip (+1)
Rob Eiben (+2)
Rob_Merritt (+22)
RobbieD (+7)
robertw315 (+2)
Rocketturtle (+1)
RogueTad (+2)
ronin (+1)
Rookie (+1)
Rookie1549 (+1)
ROTC1983 (+14)
Rowan (+11)
Royal Black Watch (+4)
rrmorton (+2)
rslifka (+11)
Rubyeye (+9)
RunningMn9 (+4)
russect (+2)
ryanherrin (+7)
ryanhills (+1)
Ryland (+1)

S
Sam Hell (+40)
Samurai (+6)
SangYuP (+1)
sanjuro (+10)
ScaryMike (+1)
scholt (+4)
Schroeder (+1)
scraper (+26)
Screwtape (+1)
scubabbl (+4)
SEALZ TomEgun (+1)
Serlesh (+37)
setaside (+72)
SG-1 (+14)
sgoldj (+5)
ShaggyDoug (+2)
Shamrock (+1)
Shazbot (+24)
shifter (+3)
shipwreck (+1)
Shohashi (+1)
Siljanus (+20)
Simon (+121)
sjsharks (+4)
skubabble (+1)
Skyride (+1)
slackerjoe (+25)
slambie (+17)
Sling409 (+1)
slobro (+47)
Smoove_B (+9)
Snuble (+2)
snukadaman (+3)
Solarisgax (+2)
Soulbringer (+2)
SOUP (+1)
Speaker2Animals (+101)
Spicy J (+9)
Spicy Jack (+4)
Spiff (+2)
spigot (+26)
Splooger (+6)
Sponge (+1)
SquireSCA (+1)
St_Dysan (+12)
SteelerForLife (+1)
Steve (+4)
stevemn (+2)
steveywunder (+1)
Sticky Green (+1)
stiffler (+6)
stolazi (+49)
Strom (+9)
Strummer (+1)
Sudy Nym (+10)
SuperHiro (+1)
swhitecr (+33)
Sword of Good Trading (+1)
Szgany (+28)

T
Tao (+1)
Tazman (+1)
TC Weidner (+4)
TebunkerTheNextGeneration (+33)
Tech-nut (+1)
Teggy (+1)
The Chauffeur (+1)
The Fringe (+2)
The Mad Hatter (+2)
The Meal (+44)
The Nature Boy (+9)
The_Man (+10)
The_Unknown_Bastard (+7)
TheGameAh (+2)
TheMissingLink (+7)
Thin_j (+1)
Thomas Covenant (+1) (-1)
Thoresten (+2)
tiktokman (+29)
Tim (+5)
Tim Frederick (+5)
Tim Maynard (+27)
tjbish (+2)
TJG_Marantz (+3)
Tokek (+7)
Toml (+1)
tony72 (+2)
toonces (+30)
Torfish (+21)
toxenocide (+1)
TradeAble (+43)
trav (+19)
Trevor Balla (+3)
Trey (+3)
tripcrow (+31)
Trooper_X (+4)
tru1cy (+13)
trueheart78 (+16)
TSS (+7) (-9)
Turtle (+5)
Two_Sheds (+12)

U
Ummagumma (+1)
Unbreakable (+1)
USAF Medic (+2)

V
Valael (+1)
vballbounce18 (+4)
VegasD (+21)
vegtable7 (+5)
Veloxi (+1)
venant (+4)
vermin (+9)
Victurbo (+6)
Vidiot (+1)
Vinda-Lou (+14)
Vortex_X (+1)
VT (+11)

W
walter (+1)
wanderingoutlaw (+1)
wankerjr (+3)
Warlord_Z (+1)
Warning (+55)
WEB (+3)
Whipsnade (+4)
Whiteboyskim (+49)
Windows95 (+10)
Wookiee007 (+21)
Working Mike (+4)
Worm (+1)

X
Xbox Gamer (+3)
xenocide (+12)
x-eyed|mary (+10)
XMANN (+28)

Y
YellowKing (+69)

Z
Zarkon (+18)
Zaxxon (+7)
zekester (+16)
Zero (+31)
Zicron (+1)
zigdaddy (+3)
Zim (+2)
Zinj (+4)
Zoyd (+21)

PROBLEMS:
MAC (nick included but no feedback listed in the last update)
HappyDog (nick included but no feedback listed in the last update)

[helot2000]

Big plus 1 to Paul Roberts for a great trade. Fast, friendly, I would gladly make another trade with him in the future.

[Holman]

And a +1 right back to helot2000 for a great trade. Enjoy the movie, especially Rene and Catherine. Rowr!

[Kaigen]

+1 to setaside

[Grundbegriff]

+1 to Ralph-Wiggum for a great deal on some GBA stuff.

[dobberhd]

+1 naedeck. Thanks for the PIFF

[warning]

+1 to Kaigen for Vampire.

[Skinypupy]

Big +1 to Montag for the Morrowind mods DVD.

[jrodstrigger]

+1 to Depward for Valkyrie Profile + Star Ocean

[wankerjr]

+1 to Austin for Doom 3.

Even sent me the box in near perfect condition!

[Depward]

+1 for jrodstrigger - very quick payment and great communication!

[Holman]

+1 to Vinda-Lou for a great exchange--and special thanks for the quick shipping to a man with his family out of town!

[yossar]

+1 to Chaoz for UT2K4/Homeworld 2.

I also had a +1 from Eliot (who didn't make the transition to this forum?) that must have been lost in that August to October period. Posting here should be enough to fix that?

[philosophist]

+1 to lokiju for Knights of the Old Republic, PC

[Grundbegriff]

Posting here should be enough to fix that?

Yes

[lokiju]

+1 to philosophist for a quick and easy payment.

[Kaigen]

+1 to warning for Dawn of War.

[magic]

+1 to Kaigen for the Gamecube freebie. Thanks mate

[warning]

+1 to Lassr for some great Piffage!

[Boudreaux]

+1 to animal114 for NFS: Underground 2 with Armed and Dangerous thrown in to boot. Smooth trade, made it in 5 days all the way from Canada.

[Dogstar]

+ 1 to LordNine for quick payment!

[setaside]

+1 EduardoX for the freebie.
+1 Darkfyre for his part of a 3-way trade with Kaigen.

[animal114]

+1 to Boudreaux for the brand-new copy of NFS HP2.

[Eduardo X]

+1 to Warning for Frequency!

[Lordnine]

+1 for AndyM Fast and reliable

[Dogstar]

+ 1 to Aenima for a quick and easy trade of HL2!

[Rubyeye]

+1 to Mithridates for a trade that went perfectly smooth.

[Ænima]

+1 to AndyM for the prompt KOTOR II goodness.

[Vinda-Lou]

+1 to Mithridates. Very fast and easy trade. Thanks!

[Vinda-Lou]

+1 to Paul Roberts. Excellent person to trade with.

[YellowKing]

Big +1 to Rob for Freedom Force. Extremely fast and smooth trade. Thanks again!

[rob]

And a +1 to YellowKing as well - thanks!

r

[Dogstar]

+1 to Setaside for a quick and easy trade!