That is not dead which can eternal lie, and with strange aeons bring us some web forums whereupon we can gather
http://garbi.online/forum/
Has purge posted anything since this post?purge wrote:Dammit! The only good remus is a dead remus.Vorret wrote:Wow... my conspiracy theory was right.
RW
Holding off on voting, per request above. Vorret, are you looking to give them opportunity?
According to him, he's very busy (he was also very busy last game and he was a wolf).theohall wrote:Has purge posted anything since this post?purge wrote:Dammit! The only good remus is a dead remus.Vorret wrote:Wow... my conspiracy theory was right.
RW
Holding off on voting, per request above. Vorret, are you looking to give them opportunity?
He posted a couple of times about how our misses (and got into it with Grund in the process) but nothing else since Monday.theohall wrote:Has purge posted anything since this post?purge wrote:Dammit! The only good remus is a dead remus.Vorret wrote:Wow... my conspiracy theory was right.
RW
Holding off on voting, per request above. Vorret, are you looking to give them opportunity?
While looking at Purge stuff, I found this.... I need to rethink RMC and his possible guilt level.Bakhtosh wrote: Something about this post has been bugging me today, and I think I figured it out in the shower tonight.
At first, I thought it was, "I could vote for anyone except myself." That, in itself, is a wolfish thing to say. Or rather, it's a wolfish thing to think.
But the epiphany that came to me is about the first part, "I'm with triggercut, but just in his thoughts."
It sounds like he's claiming to be in communication with Trig. That seems awfully heavy-handed for a special powered on Day 1. I would hope the cabal, seer, and mentalist aren't throwing out clues like that (God help us all).
I'm debating on if this is a wolf throwing out false clues to use later to claim a role, or a sorcerer letting wolf Triggercut know that he was scanned and found last night.
Honestly, I'm leaning towards the second of those two. I feel pretty strong about lynching RMC, but if he's the sorcerer, he'll show up human. Same with Trig - if we lynch him and he shows up human, that doesn't tell us anything specific about RMC.
Something about Newcastle's haikus makes me nervous, but right now, I think we have a more likely threat in RMC and/or Triggercut.
Withdraw Newcastle
RMC
I'm switching my vote, but would be open to stretching the neck of either of these two. And just so we're clear, I'm not convinced that Newcastle is human, but I haven't seen anything from him that worries me as much as the post above.
One of the first substancial posts from Purge. Looking back, there is a whole lot of bad in this post. (20/20 hindsight and all that). Remus wouldn't spoof a role that could be disproven (come forward and disprove it seer!), but he doesn't trust Remus, but the seer should stay hidden for a while longer. The seance stuff is good and what the village should be thinking (IMO). This could be a real villager talking, but could also easily be a wolf supporting Remus's move.purge wrote:Frankly this feels wrong. Remuswolf wouldn't be so stupid as to spoof a role that could be disproven, and since LL clearly is alive and well, at best guess NC could have been 1 of 3 cabal. IIRC LL confirmed he was not, do that leaves one person to spoof as the other two were evil.
I'm ok with voting, but the seance should be saved. The cabal will be around to answer the NC issue. I don't trust Remus. The only good Remus is a dead one.
If the seer is not remus then they are likely alive. this simplifies their job. if Remuswolf manages to kill one player in a false lynch, the game is big enough, and they are at such a disadvantage that we can afford it for the seer to scan tonight and possibly even tomorrow night before revealing.
If remus is the seer, we can look forward to him leading us to failure.
Sent from my Nokia 920
Actually I think this is a great point, and since we have timeredrun wrote:One of the first substancial posts from Purge. Looking back, there is a whole lot of bad in this post. (20/20 hindsight and all that). Remus wouldn't spoof a role that could be disproven (come forward and disprove it seer!), but he doesn't trust Remus, but the seer should stay hidden for a while longer. The seance stuff is good and what the village should be thinking (IMO). This could be a real villager talking, but could also easily be a wolf supporting Remus's move.purge wrote:Frankly this feels wrong. Remuswolf wouldn't be so stupid as to spoof a role that could be disproven, and since LL clearly is alive and well, at best guess NC could have been 1 of 3 cabal. IIRC LL confirmed he was not, do that leaves one person to spoof as the other two were evil.
I'm ok with voting, but the seance should be saved. The cabal will be around to answer the NC issue. I don't trust Remus. The only good Remus is a dead one.
If the seer is not remus then they are likely alive. this simplifies their job. if Remuswolf manages to kill one player in a false lynch, the game is big enough, and they are at such a disadvantage that we can afford it for the seer to scan tonight and possibly even tomorrow night before revealing.
If remus is the seer, we can look forward to him leading us to failure.
Sent from my Nokia 920
I'm not sure what you are reading into what I wrote - Purge moved up in my suspect list based on the post, not down. As for my vote - I don't think Vorret is going anywhere today, and I'm fine with that. I've yet to have a chance to continue reading on from page 11, which is where I left off on my last re-read, so I'm still short on putting new knowledge of the past 15 pages with old postings and seeing what stands out. I'm curious as to what a Purge vote would tell us. I'm hoping you'll make a stand as to whom you think should be lynched and why - with you being the generic unproven.RMC wrote:Actually I think this is a great point, and since we have timeredrun wrote:One of the first substancial posts from Purge. Looking back, there is a whole lot of bad in this post. (20/20 hindsight and all that). Remus wouldn't spoof a role that could be disproven (come forward and disprove it seer!), but he doesn't trust Remus, but the seer should stay hidden for a while longer. The seance stuff is good and what the village should be thinking (IMO). This could be a real villager talking, but could also easily be a wolf supporting Remus's move.purge wrote:Frankly this feels wrong. Remuswolf wouldn't be so stupid as to spoof a role that could be disproven, and since LL clearly is alive and well, at best guess NC could have been 1 of 3 cabal. IIRC LL confirmed he was not, do that leaves one person to spoof as the other two were evil.
I'm ok with voting, but the seance should be saved. The cabal will be around to answer the NC issue. I don't trust Remus. The only good Remus is a dead one.
If the seer is not remus then they are likely alive. this simplifies their job. if Remuswolf manages to kill one player in a false lynch, the game is big enough, and they are at such a disadvantage that we can afford it for the seer to scan tonight and possibly even tomorrow night before revealing.
If remus is the seer, we can look forward to him leading us to failure.
Sent from my Nokia 920
Withdraw Purge
So do you still think that Vorret is the best candidate? (Just going on where your vote is.
Problem is, purge posted so little that it's hard to get a read on him.redrun wrote:I'm not sure what you are reading into what I wrote - Purge moved up in my suspect list based on the post, not down. As for my vote - I don't think Vorret is going anywhere today, and I'm fine with that. I've yet to have a chance to continue reading on from page 11, which is where I left off on my last re-read, so I'm still short on putting new knowledge of the past 15 pages with old postings and seeing what stands out. I'm curious as to what a Purge vote would tell us. I'm hoping you'll make a stand as to whom you think should be lynched and why - with you being the generic unproven.RMC wrote:Actually I think this is a great point, and since we have timeredrun wrote:One of the first substancial posts from Purge. Looking back, there is a whole lot of bad in this post. (20/20 hindsight and all that). Remus wouldn't spoof a role that could be disproven (come forward and disprove it seer!), but he doesn't trust Remus, but the seer should stay hidden for a while longer. The seance stuff is good and what the village should be thinking (IMO). This could be a real villager talking, but could also easily be a wolf supporting Remus's move.purge wrote:Frankly this feels wrong. Remuswolf wouldn't be so stupid as to spoof a role that could be disproven, and since LL clearly is alive and well, at best guess NC could have been 1 of 3 cabal. IIRC LL confirmed he was not, do that leaves one person to spoof as the other two were evil.
I'm ok with voting, but the seance should be saved. The cabal will be around to answer the NC issue. I don't trust Remus. The only good Remus is a dead one.
If the seer is not remus then they are likely alive. this simplifies their job. if Remuswolf manages to kill one player in a false lynch, the game is big enough, and they are at such a disadvantage that we can afford it for the seer to scan tonight and possibly even tomorrow night before revealing.
If remus is the seer, we can look forward to him leading us to failure.
Sent from my Nokia 920
Withdraw Purge
So do you still think that Vorret is the best candidate? (Just going on where your vote is.
<sigh> Really?Lassr wrote:RMC is starting to feel too cuddly...
Yes. He has provided very little input, could be a wolf, was named a scan by Remus, may provide some info about Unagi, is not a special.RMC wrote:
I'll put my vote back on him if that is what everyone wants.
my feeling is do it before the weekend.RMC wrote:Want me to wait, or kill him? I say I just kill him if that is okay with everyone.
Remus wd bb2112 by death (1)
RMC wrote: Purge
There, that way, we can get our groove back on next week.
Awww, why did you delete your post?purge wrote:
Vorret wrote:Awww, why did you delete your post?purge wrote:
At least I had time to read it
Yeah it was a huge one.Lassr wrote:Vorret wrote:Awww, why did you delete your post?purge wrote:
At least I had time to read it
What!? He edited his post! That is a death sentence around here Mister...just wait...ah, never mind.
not so sure, if it was huge and helpful to the village then why not leave it up. He's alive until the lynch write up by stessier.Vorret wrote:Yeah it was a huge one.Lassr wrote:Vorret wrote:Awww, why did you delete your post?purge wrote:
At least I had time to read it
What!? He edited his post! That is a death sentence around here Mister...just wait...ah, never mind.
He's most likely a villager.
Seriously? That's some weak sauce, purge.Vorret wrote:Awww, why did you delete your post?purge wrote:
At least I had time to read it