I thought you had to run into the dog first, before you talk to the blacksmith? My vague recollection is that you find him outside of town on the road. I think either direction, so you may have to check both.Jaymann wrote: Sat Apr 15, 2023 10:56 pm I fired this up to see the enhanced graphics and how it stands up over time (great). I'm playing a sneaky thief, no mods but I cheated some weapons and armor and money for a horse. Then I went to Falkreath to get the immortal dog quest from the blacksmith. To my surprise he did not offer it and the dog was nowhere to be found.
Instead I did some quests for the Jarl until he made me a thane. As a reward I got a warrior companion named Rayya - I don't remember that at all. So did they replace the dog exploit with a real companion?
When you are a thane, I think you get a steward. I always immediately by the land and start building my house; and assign the steward to the house. Maybe if you don't do that, then the person becomes a follower? I've never run into that.