Octopus Overlords

Lagom Lite wrote:

tru1cy wrote:yar and shit

 remus west 
 


I have no reason to vote for Remus only that it's the first day and I am voting blind. I will most likely change my vote

Yes, that's how it usually goes on Day 1. Your over-explanation is pretty interesting since you're not a rookie player.

 tru1cy 
 

This.

 tru1cy 
 


Since when has tru1cy ever explained himself...

 withdraw Remus West 
 

Well, other people seem suspicious. I shall pile on!

 tru1cy 
 


I'm open to being talked out if it, though.

How *do* people decide their choices on Day One, anyway?

BTW, when i am lynched pay attention to everyone that jumped on me for my normal play

tru1cy is kind of talkative today.

As to how folks decide:
1) Rememer the only good Remus West is a dead Remus West
2) Look how folks post and try to remember if they are doing something out of character (this does not work with Scoop because he is always some kind of character
3) Silent villagers need to be eliminated because they aren't helping the village with their silence
4) #3 is not always true.
5) Guess.

Votes -

Remus West (2) - Truicy, Theohall,
Truicy (4) - Lagom Lite, BB2112, Holman,
Scoop (1) - Vorret,

Majority is 8

No Votes Cast - Remus West, Qantaga, Mr. Bubbles, RMC, Scoop, El Guapo, Proner, Lassr,

Whar the rest of these pirates be?

Holman wrote:Well, other people seem suspicious. I shall pile on!

 tru1cy 
 


I'm open to being talked out if it, though.

How *do* people decide their choices on Day One, anyway?

Geez, dude. You may as well have just quoted him and changed the name in the accuse tags.

Time to poke the innocents...ikfj dsfsd dslfs; nfasd fasd;jf nsakd gibberish I know what I did there..d;lkjfsafasdf. GIBreaertaaaBERISH srtrset. . . GrtaretaeaIBBERISH . . . .

 BB2112 
 

As long as you know I'm innocent...

 Scoop20906 
 

Scoop20906 wrote:Time to poke the innocents...ikfj dsfsd dslfs; nfasd fasd;jf nsakd gibberish I know what I did there..d;lkjfsafasdf. GIBreaertaaaBERISH srtrset. . . GrtaretaeaIBBERISH . . . .

 BB2112 
 

FYI Holman.... This is an example of a slip. Villagers (Pirates in this case) are supposed to poke the silents. When someone says time to poke the innocents, they are inadvertently admitting they are wolves.

 withdraw Remus West 
 


 Scoop20906 
 


While you may be a character, Scoop, this looks like a major faux pas.

Egad!

While this may be a faux pas on Scoop's part, he could be the Berserker wolf, but being this early in the game, it is worth it to take him out.

So theohall is allowed to make fun of me with "the only good Remus" comments but Scoop is not allowed to mock my famous slip?

Remus West wrote:So theohall is allowed to make fun of me with "the only good Remus" comments but Scoop is not allowed to mock my famous slip?

Remus, are you defending Scoop on Day One when no one has died???? Why???

Defending tru1cy:
Mr Bubbles
theohall

Attacking tru1cy:
(Lagom Lite)
bb2112
Holman

Acting kind of weird:
Holman (newbie?)
theohall (opportunist/helpful)
tru1cy (defensive, embarrassed)

Attacking Scoop for making a non-slip slip:
bb2112
theohall

Chatty:
Remus West
Holman
Scoop
bb2112

...

As of right now, I could change my vote to theohall, or to one of the silents.

theohall wrote:

Remus West wrote:So theohall is allowed to make fun of me with "the only good Remus" comments but Scoop is not allowed to mock my famous slip?

Remus, are you defending Scoop on Day One when no one has died???? Why???

This is a bit weird, protecting a high value friend?

Vorret wrote:

theohall wrote:

Remus West wrote:So theohall is allowed to make fun of me with "the only good Remus" comments but Scoop is not allowed to mock my famous slip?

Remus, are you defending Scoop on Day One when no one has died???? Why???

This is a bit weird, protecting a high value friend?

Who is, in your opinion, "protecting a high value friend"? Remus or theohall?

And what does "high value" mean in this sense?

(I'm trying to figure out how the game works under the hood.)

Lagom Lite wrote:

Vorret wrote:

theohall wrote:

Remus West wrote:So theohall is allowed to make fun of me with "the only good Remus" comments but Scoop is not allowed to mock my famous slip?

Remus, are you defending Scoop on Day One when no one has died???? Why???

This is a bit weird, protecting a high value friend?

Who is, in your opinion, "protecting a high value friend"? Remus or theohall?

Remus and a fellow wolf which helps solidify my scoop vote.

theohall's vote of Scoop seems to be a reach to find a reason to place a vote. I understood the mocking of Remus by Scoop, that in itself does not appear to be a wolf move, just a scoop move.

Vorret wrote:

Lagom Lite wrote:

Vorret wrote:

theohall wrote:

Remus West wrote:So theohall is allowed to make fun of me with "the only good Remus" comments but Scoop is not allowed to mock my famous slip?

Remus, are you defending Scoop on Day One when no one has died???? Why???

This is a bit weird, protecting a high value friend?

Who is, in your opinion, "protecting a high value friend"? Remus or theohall?

Remus and a fellow wolf which helps solidify my scoop vote.

You rarely find a wolf protecting another wolf in these games anymore, at least from the veteran players. Of course, it could be a veteran move to break the trend and actually protect his partner. That would really throw a wrench in things!

Lassr wrote:

Vorret wrote:

Lagom Lite wrote:

Vorret wrote:

theohall wrote:

Remus West wrote:So theohall is allowed to make fun of me with "the only good Remus" comments but Scoop is not allowed to mock my famous slip?

Remus, are you defending Scoop on Day One when no one has died???? Why???

This is a bit weird, protecting a high value friend?

Who is, in your opinion, "protecting a high value friend"? Remus or theohall?

Remus and a fellow wolf which helps solidify my scoop vote.

You rarely find a wolf protecting another wolf in these games anymore, at least from the veteran players. Of course, it could be a veteran move to break the trend and actually protect his partner. That would really throw a wrench in things!

I'm seeing it from a newbie perspective

Ah, the old day 1 runaround. The choices so far seem to be:

Remus West (2) - because he's always evil
Truicy (4) - Because he's, uh, talkative so far? This one's the most puzzling I think.
Scoop (1) - "poke the innocents". Possibly a reference to an earlier Remus slip?

So...great choices so far. The tru1cy one's the best - he writes like three sentences, admits that it's a day 1 vote without much logic behind it, and gets a vote and a train I guess based on him "over-explaining" things? Almost makes me want to vote for Lagom, but that's not much to go on either, so for now it probably makes more sense to vote for someone who we haven't really heard from.

Say:

 Qantaga 
 

Well, I guess having a possible slip to go on is better than having some talk about talkativeness to go on, so...

 withdraw Tru1cy 
 

 Scoop20906 
 

Lassr wrote:theohall's vote of Scoop seems to be a reach to find a reason to place a vote. I understood the mocking of Remus by Scoop, that in itself does not appear to be a wolf move, just a scoop move.

It was the standard first day BS vote. Remus West's reaction to it, though, makes it seem like a good one.

Qantaga wrote:We are the pirates who don't do anything
We just stay at home and lie around
And if you ask us to do anything
We'll just tell you
We don't do anything.

get off your lazy bum  Qantaga 
 

theohall wrote:

Lassr wrote:theohall's vote of Scoop seems to be a reach to find a reason to place a vote. I understood the mocking of Remus by Scoop, that in itself does not appear to be a wolf move, just a scoop move.

It was the standard first day BS vote. Remus West's reaction to it, though, makes it seem like a good one.

More horrible "logic" there.

1) I was not defending Scoop so much as pointing out how you were actually voting him for no reason. It was your move that interested me. I couldn't care less about Scoop living or dying (sorry, Scoop, it's true)

2) Now we have this lovely piece here. You believe I am a bad guy defending another bad guy. You are now trying to pin "evil" on Scoop based on my actions.

Why provide a reason for the initial vote if it was BS? Particularly a reason that can be proven incorrect by simply reading Scoop's whole post.
You are not looking for evil. You are looking for a scapegoat. I'd rather we dug around a bit more.

Votes -

Remus West (1) - Truicy,
Truicy (1) - Lagom Lite,
Scoop (4) - Vorret, Theohall, BB2112, Holman,
BB2112 (1)- Scoop,
Qantaga (2)- El Guapo, Lassr,

Majority is 8

No Votes Cast - Remus West, Qantaga, Mr. Bubbles, RMC, Proner,


If I missed anything or if there any corrections to be made, please let me know.

This is getting good. It's like an episode of Dallas! Who killed JR?

<shrug> No idea, and wouldn't a Dallas themed wolf game be kind of fun?

Well back to pirates... I say, let's vote for:

 Lassr 
 


Why? Because we lost the last game together, so I want to take my revenge out on him. Nothing to do with this game at all.

And I will change my mind most likely.

 bb2112 
 
appears to be throwing his vote around to see where it sticks. curious how this will go down

Also, Holman is randomly jumping on trains, but I've never played with him, so I don't know if this is par for the course with him


Maybe he should get the Grund newbie test if he is a new

tru1cy wrote:Also, Holman is randomly jumping on trains, but I've never played with him, so I don't know if this is par for the course with him


Maybe he should get the Grund newbie test if he is a new

I think this is only his second game so no one knows if this is par for the course with him yet

RMC wrote:This is getting good. It's like an episode of Dallas! Who killed JR?

<shrug> No idea, and wouldn't a Dallas themed wolf game be kind of fun?

Well back to pirates... I say, let's vote for:

 Lassr 
 


Why? Because we lost the last game together, so I want to take my revenge out on him. Nothing to do with this game at all.

And I will change my mind most likely.

fair enough.

Lassr wrote:

tru1cy wrote:Also, Holman is randomly jumping on trains, but I've never played with him, so I don't know if this is par for the course with him


Maybe he should get the Grund newbie test if he is a new

I think this is only his second game so no one knows if this is par for the course with him yet

I haven't even figured out whether it's better to talk or shut up!

This is my second game.

Holman wrote:
I haven't even figured out whether it's better to talk or shut up!

we prefer talker although that can get you into trouble often...

Lassr wrote:

Holman wrote:
I haven't even figured out whether it's better to talk or shut up!

we prefer talker although that can get you into trouble often...

Keep talking, and if scoop asks you to go with him alone into a corner, don't do it...ever...

Lassr wrote:

Qantaga wrote:We are the pirates who don't do anything
We just stay at home and lie around
And if you ask us to do anything
We'll just tell you
We don't do anything.

get off your lazy bum  Qantaga 
 

I'm going to throw myself onto the  Qantaga 
 
train for now.

I'm gone for like six months and this is my first game back and I come back to this crap? WTF?

What have I exactly done to get this many votes??