Octopus Overlords

Lassr wrote:

Lassr wrote:

Vorret wrote:To me Scoop is acting like good Scoop but I might be missing something

Scoop is acting odd.

I don't know if it is good odd or bad odd though. My gut is starting to think good but I haven't bothered to move my vote yet.

I hit submit to soon...

my hesitancy on my moving my vote is centered around his admission after the last game that he does not handle being a bad guy well and the lying bothers him. So I keep wondering if this is his approach to handling that pressure. Disinterest and absence.

And let's not forget that he actually followed my lead at one point in time and voted for El Guapo. <shrug> Not saying he is a wolf, but actually following me(even a harmless day one vote) is still following me.

Lassr wrote:

Lassr wrote:

Vorret wrote:To me Scoop is acting like good Scoop but I might be missing something

Scoop is acting odd.

I don't know if it is good odd or bad odd though. My gut is starting to think good but I haven't bothered to move my vote yet.

I hit submit to soon...

my hesitancy on my moving my vote is centered around his admission after the last game that he does not handle being a bad guy well and the lying bothers him. So I keep wondering if this is his approach to handling that pressure. Disinterest and absence.

Fair point, I prefer scoop to EG but I'd prefer Theo over Scoop, sadly, since he's in the "good" list he's untouchable for now which is annoying (such a long list).

I guess we can move on with that lynch and get some more info going into tomorrow

 Scoop 
 

Lagom Lite wrote:you people whine about my list. I asked you to play ball for ONE DAY, maybe two so the Seer and village wouldn't waste lynches and scans on good players. So far the plan has worked out ok except Remus felt the need to step forward already, I guess there is wisdom there I don't understand.

Lagom, I want you to know that I liked your play. It gave impetus to the game on Day 1 and, most importantly, gave us a lot of discussion that can be used both now and later into the game.

However, I can like your play and not like your list.

Your list did net us a wolf on Day 1. Even so, it was a bit of luck. Had the train not taken off on Bakhtosh, two of the three leading lynch candidates were (likely) specials in trig and Remus (redrun was the third, but he was on the good list and unlikely to be lynched).

And, while I admire your efforts and salute your play, Unagi is correct when he points out that, once the Cabalists are removed, there are more potential wolves on your good list (6) than on your bad list (5).

I am going to give it until tonight to see if the two remaining CabaMentalists reveal. If they don't, I'll cast a vote for someone in the bad list.

sigh...

Senechal ..


Hate mass reveals

Preceptor

stessier wrote:
Against Scoop (4) - Lassr, RMC, pr0ner, El Guapo
Against El Guapo (2) - redrun, Lagom LIte
Against trig (1) - Scoop20906
Against Vorret (1) - LordMortis
Against LordMortis (1) - theohall

No votes (10) - Remus West, Qantaga, purge, bb2112, Chaosraven, tru1cy, Vorret, triggercut, Grundbegriff, Unagi

Given Scoop's play on Trig, I wonder if he is the beserker.
Given that my major threat list is Scoop, Lassr, RMC (with BB2112 and El Guapo as alternatives), I still find the Scoop vote interesting.
I'd fine with Lassr, RMC, or El Guapo today, but I'd really rather wait a day on Scoop.
If we do find a wolf in one of the above - yeah, at that point I'd advise the hunter to shoot Scoop.
IMO, YMMV.

Wow.. So who is still hidden? Hunter..Is about it, huh?

Well at least we can but all unconfirmed into the possible bad list, and the confirmed into their own list.

Off to a meeting.

tru1cy wrote:Senechal ..

theohall wrote:Preceptor

Cupcake

tru1cy wrote:sigh...

Senechal ..


Hate mass reveals

theohall wrote:Preceptor

Chaosraven wrote:I say it's pr0ner, theohall, and RMC.

Ok, let me remove theo from that

redrun wrote: Given Scoop's play on Trig, I wonder if he is the beserker.

I'm wondering that also. Instead of trying to kill the seer over the next few nights just sacrifice the the berserker to take care of him. It's puts them in a much bogger hole but it would also eliminate a huge threat to them.

redrun wrote: I'd fine with Lassr, RMC, or El Guapo today

Stay on target...remember The List.

 withdraw Scoop 
 
he may not be the zerker but it is worth considering. of all days, today is not the day we want to hit the zerker.

did we just do away with the list?

Unagi wrote:did we just do away with the list?

not that I am aware of, I think we were waiting to see if the other 2 cabal would step forward.

Guess we could just pick and vote and LL could say "STOP" if we are about to lynch a cabal, or the target himself just say stop.

Lassr wrote:

Unagi wrote:did we just do away with the list?

not that I am aware of, I think we were waiting to see if the other 2 cabal would step forward.

They have stepped forward.

Since it would be sheer lunacy for tru1cy and theo to claim CabaMentalist with Lagom able to counter them, now it's:

Good:

Lagom
redrun
tru1cy
theohall

Very Likely Good:

Remus
Chaosraven
purge
triggercut

Unknowns:

Unagi
Qantaga
Lassr
RMC
bb2112
Grund
LordMortis
Vorret
El Guapo
Scoop
pr0ner

Qantaga wrote:

Lassr wrote:

Unagi wrote:did we just do away with the list?

not that I am aware of, I think we were waiting to see if the other 2 cabal would step forward.

They have stepped forward.

Sorry about that. I read your "we were" as "we're."

Lassr wrote: Guess we could just pick and vote and LL could say "STOP" if we are about to lynch a cabal, or the target himself just say stop.

And yet, this line makes me think you aren't aware that the rest of the cabal has revealed.

I'm so confused.

Unagi wrote:did we just do away with the list?

Yes, the list is now obsolete.

Qantaga wrote:

Lassr wrote: Guess we could just pick and vote and LL could say "STOP" if we are about to lynch a cabal, or the target himself just say stop.

And yet, this line makes me think you aren't aware that the rest of the cabal has revealed.

I'm so confused.

Yes, I was unaware. I thought I had read every new post. I must have missed it.

redrun wrote: I'm the mentalist.

tru1cy wrote:Senechal ..

theohall wrote:Preceptor

The specificity of these claims makes me sincerely hope that this was a pre-arranged, iocane-laced strategy.

I'm surprised that the three of you (redrun, tru1cy, theo) didn't all come out as generic CabaMentalists.

Lassr wrote:

Unagi wrote:did we just do away with the list?

not that I am aware of, I think we were waiting to see if the other 2 cabal would step forward.

Guess we could just pick and vote and LL could say "STOP" if we are about to lynch a cabal, or the target himself just say stop.

Lassr, let me help.

2 people from The List just posted random words from out of no-where.... tru1cy's post included a 'sigh' and a 'I hate mass reveals'...

Then redrun came in (he knows who on The List was Cabal) and spoke about his suspects, and listed a number of people on The List.

ah, I see it now. There was no "I AM CABAL" post just a simple listing their name that I did not recognize at first.

Qantaga wrote:I'm surprised that the three of you (redrun, tru1cy, theo) didn't all come out as generic CabaMentalists.

I'd advice redrun, tru1cy and theohall to not comment on that.

Qantaga, it's quite possible that redrun is a cabalist and faked on behalf of the true mentalist.

Well then

 withdraw vorret
accuse bb2112 
 


bb2112
vorret
lassr
Grund
Guapo
RMC
Scoop


The field.. Not sure what the field is at this point...

It looks like

Unagi
pr0ner



LL
Redrun
tru1cy
theo
lordmortis

Contingent on Newcastle

chaosraven
purge
Remus West
Triggercut

In that case,  bb2112 
 

jinx, you owe me a coke.

 bb2112 
 

Missed one

bb2112
vorret
lassr
Grund
Guapo
RMC
Scoop

Unagi
qantaga
pr0ner


LL
Redrun
tru1cy
theo
lordmortis

Contingent on Newcastle

chaosraven
purge
Remus West
Triggercut[/quote]

huh, 3 almost simultaneous votes on BB

Unagi wrote:

Qantaga wrote:I'm surprised that the three of you (redrun, tru1cy, theo) didn't all come out as generic CabaMentalists.

I'd advice redrun, tru1cy and theohall to not comment on that.

Qantaga, it's quite possible that redrun is a cabalist and faked on behalf of the true mentalist.

Absolutely, I agree that redrun, tru1cy, and theohall should not coment on that, nor Lagom for that matter. Thus, the line in my post above the one you quoted that said I hope this is a pre-arranged, iocane-laced strategy.

However, that doesn't mean that it shouldn't be considered by those not named Lagom, redrun, tru1cy, or theo, since you know darn well that the wolves are considering it (or will be as the game grows longer).

I do believe that something just permitted us to make that vote.

(that was to Lassr)

uuhhhh...... good thing you guys pointed it out I thought they we're random words as well.

Vorret wrote:uuhhhh...... good thing you guys pointed it out I thought they we're random words as well.

I didn't even get it. What I got was redrun pointing to people on LL list. So I assumed I missed it and was trusting what the peanut gallery.

Qantaga wrote: Unknowns:
Unagi
Qantaga
Lassr
RMC
bb2112
Grund
LordMortis
Vorret
El Guapo
Scoop
pr0ner

I would love to see folks threat lists - for the above names only.

redrun wrote:

Qantaga wrote: Unknowns:
Unagi
Qantaga
Lassr
RMC
bb2112
Grund
LordMortis
Vorret
El Guapo
Scoop
pr0ner

I would love to see folks threat lists - for the above names only.

my tops were Scoop, BB2112, Lord Mortis, & Unagi but when Lord Mortis and Unagi voted BB the same time I did I have to rethink my list.

 bb2112 
 


guess we are going to assume the Hunter was Newcastle or chooses to stay quiet... Cabal gets Newcastle info and a minimum of 2 alive to tell us tomorrow. If Newc the Hunter, wolves likely kill Remus and trig pulls the Medium trick (question: does Seer get results if He or His target get killed the same night?)

Chaosraven wrote:(question: does Seer get results if He or His target get killed the same night?)

If my target is killed then we all get the result - Human. If the wolves kill me then I still get the result and can share it through the seance the next day. This was brought up previously.

I was too busy in the FormerlyConsideredFurry Anonymous forums to read that, I guess.

Sweet.

JOHNNYANGEL YOUR RIDE IS HERE!

Uh, bb, if yer the Hunter, LM started it.

Yep and I stand by my thought on the matter.

And if bb2112 is the hunter and I get shot that kinda sucks, if only because with everyone else revealed the hunter is safe for a good long time while the wolves should be forced to kill (beyond the fact that he'd be shooting a villager) and would be able to do something like shoot remus if newcastle is the seer or trig if newcastle is the medium.